2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Should we have anonymous bidding for free agency?

No - Keep it like now where everyone knows who is bidding what at all times with 100% information listed.
13
25%
Yes - List the bids but always hide the team names associated with those bids.
26
50%
Mixed - Keep bids anonymous if under $2M, but publish team names behind top bids if above $2M.
5
10%
Mixed - Keep the high bid team anonymous but mention which teams involoved that have placed bids on this player during the current negotiations in no particular order.
8
15%
 
Total votes: 52

soonertf
Posts: 731
Joined: Fri Jul 13, 2007 9:31 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by soonertf »

You tell them Sir!
AFFL - Dallas Cowboy's GM
Regular Season Record - 109-72
Playoff Record - 12-4
AFFL Bowl Record - 3-0

3x AFFL Champions - 2009, 2011, 2018
3x NFC Champions - 2009, 2011, 2018
6x NFC East Champions - 2007, 2009-13
RebelFan
Posts: 469
Joined: Fri Apr 10, 2009 5:01 pm
Location: MS

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by RebelFan »

Royce R wrote:I do last minute bidding all the time.

Hate it all you want, but I got a lot of guys I'm willing to pay money for and only have 5 bids.

Why waste a bid if someone is going to bump him? Nothing is worse than bidding on someone then they get bumped twice only to let another guy I wanted go because I wasted my bid.

Thus if there is 3 teams interested let them do the bumping while I go after the other targets I want.

To me its just silly to waste a bid before you need to.
Thank You Royce! I agree 100% with everything Royce just said.

I'm a "clown".
I think it's an ideal strategy with only 5 bids per 24 hours. It's even a better strategy now that the bidding is anonymous and you don't know if you're bidding against someone with unlimited bids or someone with only 5 bids / 24 hours. I usually have a lot of possible targets and if there is a bidding war going on between 2 other GMs I can focus on other targets until that plays out.

I know I've said this before, but you guys whine too much. It's like Napa Valley around here sometimes.
GM - Chicago Bears - AFFL
GM - San Francisco 49ers - DFFL

"Talent Hoarder"
soonertf
Posts: 731
Joined: Fri Jul 13, 2007 9:31 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by soonertf »

If only we had some cheese and crackers too! :lol:
AFFL - Dallas Cowboy's GM
Regular Season Record - 109-72
Playoff Record - 12-4
AFFL Bowl Record - 3-0

3x AFFL Champions - 2009, 2011, 2018
3x NFC Champions - 2009, 2011, 2018
6x NFC East Champions - 2007, 2009-13
larry linke
Posts: 325
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 9:52 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by larry linke »

Here is a reason for the anonymous bidding, the Amendola / Bowe war. There is a good chance it is the same two GM's who keep bidding against each other with Bowe over $13 M and Amendola over $11 M. If they knew who each other were they could have reached an "agreement" millions of dollars ago as to who got who.

Larry
Minnesota
tino38
Posts: 1137
Joined: Sun Apr 12, 2009 5:39 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by tino38 »

larry linke wrote:Here is a reason for the anonymous bidding, the Amendola / Bowe war. There is a good chance it is the same two GM's who keep bidding against each other with Bowe over $13 M and Amendola over $11 M. If they knew who each other were they could have reached an "agreement" millions of dollars ago as to who got who.

Larry
Minnesota
IMO if that is the case then it is just unfortunate for those 2 GM's, however, it still does not make me feel like going back to the old way is any better. Both WR's are already making more money than a lot of GM's would care to pay. The 2 GM's in this case will not get any sympathy from me, as it will allow them less money next year to enter into bidding wars.
AFFL Patriots - Super Bowl Champion: 22’
DFFL Jets - Super Bowl Champion: 21’ & 22’
FFFL Jets - Super Bowl Champion: 17’ & 18’
BRFL Saints - Super Bowl Champion: 23’
JonC
Posts: 344
Joined: Fri Jun 22, 2012 9:10 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by JonC »

tino38 wrote:
larry linke wrote:Here is a reason for the anonymous bidding, the Amendola / Bowe war. There is a good chance it is the same two GM's who keep bidding against each other with Bowe over $13 M and Amendola over $11 M. If they knew who each other were they could have reached an "agreement" millions of dollars ago as to who got who.

Larry
Minnesota
IMO if that is the case then it is just unfortunate for those 2 GM's, however, it still does not make me feel like going back to the old way is any better. Both WR's are already making more money than a lot of GM's would care to pay. The 2 GM's in this case will not get any sympathy from me, as it will allow them less money next year to enter into bidding wars.
I think that's larry's point as well, tino.
DFFL Steelers GM: '13-'22
Regular Season Record: 77-85 (.475)
Division Championships: ’13, ’14, ’19
AFC WC Team: ’20

AFFL Bills GM: '20-?
Regular Season Record: 20-30 (.400)

BRFL Chargers GM: '21-?
Regular Season Record: 17-17 (.500)
AFC WC Team: '22
larry linke
Posts: 325
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 9:52 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by larry linke »

Jon is correct, that was my point. While from a selfish point I like to know who I am bidding against, there is advantages and disadvantages either way and as long as we all play by the same rules, it doesn't matter. Along with the draft, this is my favorite time of the year.

Thanks for all you do Troy.

Larry
Minnesota AFFL
lucky7jc
Posts: 163
Joined: Wed Aug 08, 2007 10:01 pm
Location: Tennessee

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by lucky7jc »

larry linke wrote:Here is a reason for the anonymous bidding, the Amendola / Bowe war. There is a good chance it is the same two GM's who keep bidding against each other with Bowe over $13 M and Amendola over $11 M. If they knew who each other were they could have reached an "agreement" millions of dollars ago as to who got who.

Larry
Minnesota
Someone fell in love with Brady throwing to Amendola thinking he'll be the next Wes Welker too! I hate it for them, but Danny ain't no Welker. I'm glad whoever it is spending that money though, leaves the rest of us opportunity later.
AFFL Champion - 2019
AFC Champion - 2019
Post Reply