2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Should we have anonymous bidding for free agency?

No - Keep it like now where everyone knows who is bidding what at all times with 100% information listed.
13
25%
Yes - List the bids but always hide the team names associated with those bids.
26
50%
Mixed - Keep bids anonymous if under $2M, but publish team names behind top bids if above $2M.
5
10%
Mixed - Keep the high bid team anonymous but mention which teams involoved that have placed bids on this player during the current negotiations in no particular order.
8
15%
 
Total votes: 52

sportznut
Posts: 1159
Joined: Wed Jul 11, 2007 5:09 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by sportznut »

People aren't sure if they like this or not yet? Really? As if prices aren't sky high already, knowing your rival were bidding on someone would make players even more expensive IMO.
AFFL- Raiders
MLBSA- Tigers
WLSB- Marlins
Shagg
Posts: 275
Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2007 3:47 pm
Location: Detroit

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by Shagg »

sportznut wrote:People aren't sure if they like this or not yet? Really? As if prices aren't sky high already, knowing your rival were bidding on someone would make players even more expensive IMO.
This!
E.G.K
Detroit Lions General Manager-AFFL
vikingfan
Posts: 178
Joined: Thu Mar 19, 2009 9:10 am
Location: South Dakota

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by vikingfan »

I just miss playing DEFENSE. Its starting to grow on me, I may be admitting I was wrong on this and it was a good idea. Not yet, but close.
Shagg wrote:
sportznut wrote:People aren't sure if they like this or not yet? Really? As if prices aren't sky high already, knowing your rival were bidding on someone would make players even more expensive IMO.
This!
RebelFan
Posts: 469
Joined: Fri Apr 10, 2009 5:01 pm
Location: MS

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by RebelFan »

It really adds a new element to the League Home page, where it tells who signed who..
GM - Chicago Bears - AFFL
GM - San Francisco 49ers - DFFL

"Talent Hoarder"
Jared A
Posts: 1130
Joined: Tue Jul 31, 2007 3:18 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by Jared A »

I doubt it's keeping prices lower, but it's at least making it so that specific GM's can't pick on specific GM's :) which I like and dislike at the same time... :P
larry linke
Posts: 325
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 9:52 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by larry linke »

I can't wait to see who is offering Dwayne "head case" Bowe a 7 year contract at $9.5 M per year and a $21 M, yes $21 M dollar signing bonus. Then there is Danny Amendola, who has missed half of my games in the last two years to broken bones because he is so small but has a 7 year, $8.0 M per year offer with an $11 M dollar signing bonus. I am picking on this two free agents because they were my players last year.

I like to know who I am bidding against for two reasons. One is you know who you may want to enter into a bidding war depending on their available funds. The other reason is that there is always some clown who tops your bid with 3 minutes left.

Larry
Minnesota AFFL
soonertf
Posts: 731
Joined: Fri Jul 13, 2007 9:31 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by soonertf »

I like to know who I am bidding against for two reasons. One is you know who you may want to enter into a bidding war depending on their available funds. The other reason is that there is always some clown who tops your bid with 3 minutes left.
That strategy annoys me too, but unfortunately a lot of GMs use the last minute bidding as a strategy. I think I lean more toward wanting to know who is bidding, but this has definitely been intriguing. I originally thought it would be to my favor to have then hidden, but it definitely hasn't helped yet! :)

I agree on the two WRs, but unfortunately all WRs were crazy high this off-season. I was shocked to see what Jordy Nelson signed for.
AFFL - Dallas Cowboy's GM
Regular Season Record - 109-72
Playoff Record - 12-4
AFFL Bowl Record - 3-0

3x AFFL Champions - 2009, 2011, 2018
3x NFC Champions - 2009, 2011, 2018
6x NFC East Champions - 2007, 2009-13
Adam K
Posts: 300
Joined: Tue Aug 28, 2007 9:07 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by Adam K »

larry linke wrote:I can't wait to see who is offering Dwayne "head case" Bowe a 7 year contract at $9.5 M per year and a $21 M, yes $21 M dollar signing bonus. Then there is Danny Amendola, who has missed half of my games in the last two years to broken bones because he is so small but has a 7 year, $8.0 M per year offer with an $11 M dollar signing bonus. I am picking on this two free agents because they were my players last year.

I like to know who I am bidding against for two reasons. One is you know who you may want to enter into a bidding war depending on their available funds. The other reason is that there is always some clown who tops your bid with 3 minutes left.

Larry
Minnesota AFFL
I personally like the change. Sure I would like to know for the same selfish reasons. But there was always a clown last year. It is better to not know who the clown is.

To be honest, I got better deals last year - because you could tell the person you were going up against was running out of money.

I know change can be difficult for some of you, but this is a good move IMO.

It adds an element to free agency. I bet the AFFL transaction page is getting record traffic.
Onyxgem
Posts: 758
Joined: Mon Jul 30, 2007 3:32 pm

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by Onyxgem »

larry linke wrote:
I like to know who I am bidding against for two reasons. One is you know who you may want to enter into a bidding war depending on their available funds. The other reason is that there is always some clown who tops your bid with 3 minutes left.

Larry
Minnesota AFFL
Yup there are always going to be guys who don't do anything other than look at the about to sign page and see somebody who might be getting a deal and bump it the min...that is almost as bad sa the multi-million dollar deals getting 100k RB added or something stupid like that.
Royce R
Posts: 687
Joined: Thu Aug 02, 2007 12:03 am
Location: South Dakota

Re: 2013 RULES: Anonymous Bidding

Post by Royce R »

I do last minute bidding all the time.

Hate it all you want, but I got a lot of guys I'm willing to pay money for and only have 5 bids.

Why waste a bid if someone is going to bump him? Nothing is worse than bidding on someone then they get bumped twice only to let another guy I wanted go because I wasted my bid.

Thus if there is 3 teams interested let them do the bumping while I go after the other targets I want.

To me its just silly to waste a bid before you need to.
AFFL - Titans GM since 2007
96 - 62 - 2 regular season
6 playoff appearances
4 division titles
2 conference titles
1 AFFL title
Post Reply